Thereasons that Grant Penrod states in his article“Anti-intellectualism: Why we hate smart kids” are thatintelligent students are mistreated due to stereotyping, famouspeople, and their love of money. Smart kids are dubbed as “nerds”and the term stands for a person that has no social life and all theyhave is schoolwork (Penrod, 754). The writer provides pieces ofevidence from some online comments that he read. An example is one ofthe comments posted by a student that says ““Man how I hatenerds… if ever had a toy gun with me… I would probably blow eachone of their… heads off,” ((Penrod, 754). Such a comment ishurtful and shows a clear image of the severity of the problem. Ifind Penrod’s argument persuasive since he states facts from anemotional approach whereby he understands the challenges thatintelligent pupils face.
Thetitle of the text tells the readers that the intended audience is theschoolmates of the smart kids. Penrod feels that the target audiencedoes not hold any values since they pick on their fellow studentswithout any consideration for their feelings or self-esteem. Thewriter reaches out to the readers by speaking on behalf of thevictimized pupils and tries to show how damaging negative attitudescan have on a student’s life. I think Grant is successful since themessage is powerful and touching. Any person reading the textempathizes with the intelligent students.
Theclaims that Penrod makes on social exclusion are real since moststudents feel that one cannot achieve academic success while alsohaving an active social life. Thus, students that are below oraverage in classwork tend to believe they are separate from thosethat excel in academics. Therefore, intelligent students grow uplacking some social skills that they were denied during the time theywere in school.
Ido not agree with Penrod. Currently, success in any sector is toughto attain without education. Many of the present celebrities have aminimum of high school diploma. The entertainment and athleticindustry are saturated with many people. For one to find recognition,they should stand out. Having proper education is the most logicaloption. The evidence that denies Penrod’s argument is that themedia promotes many sports athletes that had to win a collegescholarship that enabled them to enter the professional fieldsmoothly.
Penrod,Grant. “Anti-Intellectualism: Why We Hate the Smart Kids.” TheNorton Field Guide to Writing with Readings and Handbook.3rd ed. Ed. Marilyn Moller. New York: W.W. Norton & Co., 2013.754-758. Print.